thecriticalcouple
  • Home
  • The Food Blog
  • CC Cocktails
  • Wellbeing
  • Other Stuff
  • Contact

Five Fields, Fine Dining, Not Five Guys

5/8/2013

16 Comments

 
Picture
The Five Fields must be the most under the radar opening of a restaurant this year which might seem odd given the media focus on all things new and shiny. At an event we attended before our dinner, with people who usually know these things better than us, even as we say the words 'five fields' people are already shaking their head, agreed on only one thing, no one has ever heard of it. In part, Five Fields is so off trend that maybe denial is the most socially acceptable line to take, even if you know it well.

Why is it off trend? Let us count the ways: Five Fields is fine dining, yes, we said it, and didn't even feel a need to misspell it. No burger, brasserie or steak house here. It's in Chelsea, not Shoreditch. It is traditional, a Michelin pleaser, expect an amuse bouche (several in fact), pre desserts, petit fours, luxury ingredients and tasting menus. They have table cloths, they take bookings, no one has a visible tattoo while the kitchen is also invisible to the diners. There's not even a little window allowing you to see the top of the chef's heads.

That in itself will be enough for most reviewers to boycott it, or simply damn it before setting a foot through the door, but as was the case with Mark Twain, reports of the death of fine dining have been very much exaggerated. If you don't believe that to be true, try getting a table at Le Gavroche before October. The timing of Five Fields might be smart too if the green shoots of recovery and Lloyds TSB's share price are to be believed. The only thing we find truly quirky about Five Fields is their opening hours: they do not open for lunch and only open for dinner Tuesday to Saturday.

We visit the restaurant anonymously but we're soon recognised by Jason Walker, the Assistant Restaurant Manager, who was previously at The Ledbury and clearly has a good memory for faces. There's also a theme here: Chef Owner Taylor Bonnyman was previously of two starred Corton in New York, Head Chef Marguerite was Marcus Wareing and Pastry Chef Chris Underwood was Tom Aikens. It appears that no chances are being taken on unknowns here, everyone on staff has a serious and Michelin starred hospitality background as far as we could tell. 

What should surprise you here however is the price. Three courses at dinner is £45 and the eight course tasting menu (more like 12 courses in fact with all the extras) is £65. This we think is actually very good value and in our view unlikely to last too far beyond the initial opening. Consider that Roast in Borough Market charges £30+ for its main courses alone (without anything like the quality), while a more appropriate comparison, say Kitchen W8, cost us on our lunch time visit around £50 for three courses.

But what of the food? It's actually very good indeed with some real stand out dishes, delivering up food that succeeds in being what it wants to be. By that, we mean that food is more reminiscent of say The Square than Hibiscus, a classical backdrop with modern flourish. There's some, but not so much boundry pushing here, and we don't say that critically. Further off trend, dishes have also eschewed the more recent tendency towards three ingredients or less on a plate (think Dabbous), and instead offer more recognisable, more comfortable but still unquestionably impressive plates of food. 

The meal grows on us as we progress through it. After an amuse and pre starter, Crab with a corn sauce looks pretty, tastes good but is never destined to set the world on fire, but this is a menu that builds momentum. The next dish called Summer brings three actual dishes to the table including Serrano Ham in a pork consomme and this begins to feel more like it with us wishing this component at least were several times larger (10x perhaps). Foie Gras in a beetroot gel looks stunning with contrasting colours on the plate while acidity in the gooseberries and crunch from the bed of hazelnuts offer similar contrasts in the mouth to the beautifully smooth foie gras and made a classic luxury ingredient once again feel vibrant.

The bar keeps moving higher and the Scottish lobster is a triumph, issuing an easy challenge to those who say lobster doesn't taste of anything; this is how lobster should taste. Lamb offers a traditional and comfortable end to the savouries but here we delight over a piece of lamb crackling, the best of its kind we have ever tasted I'd wager. The lamb meanwhile packed flavour and shares the qualities of the lobster dish: this is how lamb is supposed to taste and is exactly how it should be cooked.

Special mention goes to desserts which have a strong sense of their own identity and are less traditional than the savouries. Pastry Chef Chris Underwood is formerly Tom Aikens and that complexity and approach to detail that he no doubt inherited from Tom shows through, but most importantly, the desserts really work well. In particular, one dessert pairs the classic combination of Coconut Sorbet and Chocolate (done here as a soil), but adds in garden peas to the dish also giving a clean freshness that tailors it fantastically to the hot weather and prompting you to feel that you've discovered a food revelation. Put it this way, this blog features no other dessert with peas in, and nor do David Everitt-Matthias's or Phil Howard's seminal dessert cookbooks feature peas, but here they made it a highlight of the dessert, and the meal overall. One can only applaud.

For £65, this is an awful lot of food. For £65, this is great food, where huge amounts of time and energy have been expended with quality ingredients to craft dishes that can elbow themselves in and be noticed in a crowded London fine dining scene. It may not be fashionable, but this restaurant knows what it wants to be in food and service and achieves it. For those who care about these things, Five Fields is surely a certainty for a Michelin star. We enjoyed our meal here, we think it offers strong value for money as well as some good old fashioned cosseting. But when we reflect on where else we've been the past six months, Five Fields sticks out, memorable for all the right reasons: these days, given the quality out there, that is not an easy thing to do.
Picture
the dining room
Picture
hummus and crudite pre-meal nibble
Picture
Cornish Crab, Devonshire Caviar and Corn
Picture
"Summer" Fruits and Vegetables, Serrano Ham and Summer Truffles
Picture
Foie Gras, gooseberries and hazelnuts
Picture
Orkney Scallop, roasted, with green lentils and kaffir lime
Picture
Scottish lobster, pan fried, with green tomato, melon and almonds
Picture
Yorkshire Lamb, loin and shoulder, with carrots and charred aubergine
Picture
Pistachio and Apricot, pistachio and almond cake with honey poached apricot and vanilla
Picture
Garden Pea and Coconut, pea cassonade, with chocolate soil and coconut sorbet
Picture
Cucumber: compressed cucumber with white chocolate sorbet and basil ash meringue
Picture
petit fours
Picture
private dining
Picture
wine room/cellar
The Five Fields on Urbanspoon
Picture
16 Comments
Lee link
5/8/2013 12:48:00 am

Some very pretty plates there, especially the foie. Good to see the odd new opening in London swimming against the tide!

Reply
wendy
5/8/2013 05:34:47 am

I agree wholeheartedly. We have been a couple of times and are dreading the restaurant getting to the point where it gets 'discovered' as I am sure it will be so popular it will be impossible to get a table. We are keeping it quiet!

Reply
The Food Snob UK
5/8/2013 10:34:05 am

As usual, a well written post. Great pictures. I have just started a food photography course and my current Panosonic LUMIX simply won't cut the mustard! *sigh* I knew this was going to cost me.. Fantastic blog guys.

Reply
TCC
5/8/2013 10:50:19 am

Thanks so much for the comment as always. Good luck with the new camera whatever it turns out to be.

Reply
Hungry Hoss link
5/8/2013 11:10:35 am

Looks up my alley, this one!

Great post :-)

Reply
Taylor Bonnyman
6/8/2013 11:42:21 am

Thank you very much for your kind words. It makes all of our efforts worthwhile when we read comments like these.

Reply
TCC
6/8/2013 11:47:12 am

thank you for the comment Taylor, we wish you every success going forwards. See you all again soon we hope.

Reply
David link
9/8/2013 11:21:47 pm

That look fantastic !! Can I book the table for a old French friend ?

Reply
CK
7/8/2013 12:14:03 am

Photos are amazing! Sounds great value too. JK has booked us in already :)

Reply
Alan Spedding ( cumbriafoodie ) link
7/8/2013 02:42:48 am

Panasonic Lumix wont cut the Mustard......what a cheek Food snob ;-)
Loving the Foie gras shot , looks almost 3D. Nice clean photos Mr CC , definitely got to grips with your DOF here.
Great food , classic fine dining....Love it. Definitely one to put on the list.

Reply
Alan Spedding ( cumbriafoodie ) link
7/8/2013 02:43:44 am

Panasonic Lumix wont cut the Mustard......what a cheek Food snob ;-)
Loving the Foie gras shot , looks almost 3D. Nice clean photos Mr CC , definitely got to grips with your DOF here.
Great food , classic fine dining....Love it. Definitely one to put on the list.

Reply
Jamie H
30/9/2013 06:56:30 am

We had the tasting menu dinner this Saturday and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Attentive, friendly but not intrusive service. Pretty, beautifully executed food which was modern without being unnecessarily modish. Thoughtfully chosen matched wines. The standard of cooking and the quality of the ingredients really shone through - we both thought the veal sweetbreads the best we have ever had. Our only quibble was with the puddings which neither of enjoyed - but this was matter of personal taste rather than execution or presentation. My favourite new find for some years. We'll be going back and I've already handed out several recommendations.

Reply
Tony Lees link
17/1/2014 09:40:47 am

Eating there next Friday, so interested in the review. Please, however, drop the superfluous 'actual' - it's a redundant word, and grates accordingly. Nice review otherwise, Does anyone else think shallow depth of field has had its day in food photography, though?

Reply
TCC
17/1/2014 10:42:22 am

on depth of field, the lighting in the restaurant is low, we don't use a flash, therefore it's high ISO and wide open aperture simply to get an acceptable picture.I would actually like more depth of field but it's simply not possible in a restaurant like this.

Reply
Tony Lees link
17/1/2014 12:44:21 pm

Fair point, and well made. My comment arose from a recent unboxing of some long unread part works, 'Good Cooking' from the 1970s, and a simple observation that shots from that era were always sharp from front to back. With hindsight, this clearly means studio lighting, smaller apertures and, frankly, too much Willow Pattern!

Shellee Evans
1/4/2015 08:42:06 am

I had the privilege of visiting 2 weeks ago with a friend over from the US. The whole experience was incredible. From being escorted to the private lounge for a glass of champagne as we arrived slightly early, to the amazing meal, superb wines, attentive staff .... an unforgettable experience. Thank you.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Follow CriticalCouple on Twitter


    Categories

    All
    Bars
    Books
    Burgers
    Drink
    Fish
    Giving
    Hotel
    Places
    Pub
    Restaurants
    Seafood
    Steak
    Whisky
    Wine


    RSS Feed

We're all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars. (Oscar Wilde)