thecriticalcouple
  • Home
  • The Food Blog
  • CC Cocktails
  • Wellbeing
  • Other Stuff
  • Contact

The Walnut Tree: grounded

17/9/2012

7 Comments

 
Picture
Having just a few posts earlier poked a stick at Novikov for the bombastic and frankly nauseating claims on their website, the website of The Walnut Tree seems the perfect tonic. As a Michelin starred restaurant, they nevertheless tell you that at The Walnut Tree, there is 'no dress code or similar pomposity' and even of the food they suggest that 'this site will not offend visitors with smarmy overstatements of what's on offer'. It's certainly a pleasant change from idle boasts.

The Walnut Tree is two miles East of Abergavenny and is an obvious stop off the next day following my dinner the night before at the Crown at Whitebrook. As restaurants however, they couldn't be more different. While together they make up half of Wales's Michelin star count, the Crown is 100% fine dining, whereas The Walnut Tree remains a pub that serves great food. Overall, there seems to be a good ethos with regard to food and drink, and again on the website of the winelist they say 'I don't want to push anyone into spending more than they want so please ask if you are interested'. Everything seems a refreshing change to the norm.

A la carte starters range from £7 (panzanella) through to £16 (lobster with pea and mint) with £10-£12 accounting however for most of the choices. There's much that sounds good but I can't resist the lobster, so I don't. Before that however there's an amuse of crab and avocado which is a nice little extra to start.

The lobster with pea and mint is excellent, and would prove to be the star of the show today. Attractively presented, the lobster looks glorious. The pea and mint veloute initially gives the pea with the mint subtle on the end. It's very nicely done.

The mains range from £15 (wild mushroom risotto) to £26 (john dory with steamed courgette flower and lobster mousse). There's also pork, beef and venison on the menu but I opt for the modestly price partridge with chestnut and apple stuffing (£17). I enjoyed the flavours here but the partridge was a little tough, at times difficult to cut with a knife. It's a shame as it took the edge off the dish. With partridge in season from 1 September, it's my first this year though someone in the know recently told me that partridges will not be at their best till October, so perhaps it was the wrong choice. The dish came with potatoes that are not shown in the pictures below.

Picture
the dining room
Picture
crab and avocado
Picture
lobster pea and mint
Picture
partridge
The desserts are full of traditional and recognisably popular puddings such as sticky toffee pudding, blackberry and apple pudding and creme brulee. I opted for the lemon curd and raspberry meringue. All desserts are £8. It certainly looked entertaining and was quite nice but the meringues were chewy not gooey so the dessert mostly failed to lift above the ordinary. 
Picture
lemon curd and raspberry meringue
One feels that The Walnut Tree is what it is, a pub serving better than average food. If this were my local, I'd be happy to come here and eat often. But it failed to feel more than a pub serving better than average food and that Michelin star, whether a blessing or a curse, should mean there's a little bit of magic somewhere. Sadly, if there is a bit of magic somewhere, today, I just didn't feel it (well, maybe a little on the lobster).


Return to homepage


Picture
7 Comments
M
16/9/2012 11:08:52 pm

There is an old but amusing episode where Ramsay tries to turn around this restaurant.

www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGcM9nST3NU

Reply
thecriticalcouple
17/9/2012 04:13:51 pm

M

thanks for this. Sadly, in the UK, Channel 4 have blocked this transmission. One for our overseas readers to enjoy.

Reply
Kavey link
17/9/2012 01:48:19 am

We went a year ago, during the Abergavenny Food Festival 2012, and were really disappointed with our meal. There were a number of issues (and indeed one of the mains was removed from the final bill) and it really didn't live up to expectations at all.
This year, in contrast, we went to The Hardwick, and had a far superior experience.

Reply
Fergus
17/9/2012 02:49:36 am

Interesting there is no comment on the chef - Shaun Hill - I have to admit I have never been to the Walnut Tree, but as a family used to go to the Merchant House in Ludlow, which is to this day still the place where I had my greatest meal in my life. It was 'simple' food cooked amazingly well - there something almost poetic about it (sounds trashy I know!). Shaun is thought of by many as a silent hero, and hates the fame side of things (but am sure you know what anyway). But it was amazing in Ludlow, when it was him and one other in a tiny kitchen!

P.S Love the blog!

Reply
thecriticalcouple
17/9/2012 04:11:42 pm

Fergus,

thanks for the comment. I didn't comment on Shaun Hill because I don't feel I know enough about him to really make a comment. I understand that the Merchant House has a great reputation but I never got to eat there so decided not to say anything one way or the other.

I'm so pleased that you enjoy the blog.

Reply
Jack
17/9/2012 05:53:31 am

I admire Shaun Hill but the blurb on his website comes across, to my eyes at least, simply like inverted snobbery, and like all extremes one end of the spectrum is usually just as distasteful as the other. It smacks of insecurity, all this grooming of the visitor - why not just say nothing and let the end result speak for itself? I would not expect pomposity or offence in any establishment - I find it odd to have it specifically pointed out that there won't be any at the Walnut Tree. I read his Merchant House book some years ago and found it forthright and amusing, but I now have an image of him pacing the dining room with a stick, ensuring there is no "pomposity" going on.

Reply
thecriticalcouple
17/9/2012 04:12:45 pm

thanks Jack, I certainly see your point.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Follow CriticalCouple on Twitter


    Categories

    All
    Bars
    Books
    Burgers
    Drink
    Fish
    Giving
    Hotel
    Places
    Pub
    Restaurants
    Seafood
    Steak
    Whisky
    Wine


    RSS Feed

We're all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars. (Oscar Wilde)